Skip to main content
Menu
(615) 945-7123
This home has sold. Ask Grant Hammond about similar Hermitage listings.

Sold April 13, 2026 · $435,000

$218/sq ft

3 beds · 2 baths · 1,999 sq ft

5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage, TN 37076

Single-family home in The Peninsula · Built 1999

100.0% of its last list price In line with 5 comparable sales within 0.9 miles

MLS #3130499 · listed February 12, 2026 · updated June 24, 2026

Sale record checked .

5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage, TN 37076, a 3-bedroom, 2-bath, 1,999 sq ft home in The Peninsula, built in 1999, sold for $435,000 on April 13, 2026, 100% of its last list price, in line with 5 comparable sales within 0.9 miles.

5137 Bay Overlook Dr sale analysis

5137 Bay Overlook Dr, a 3-bedroom, 2-bath, 1,999 sq ft home in The Peninsula, Hermitage, TN 37076, sold on April 13, 2026 for $435,000, 100% of its last asking price of $434,900 (first listed for $449,900), 26 days from listing to contract, per the Realtracs closing.

It sold in line with 5 comparable sales within 0.9 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 15%) that sold between October 30, 2025 and March 31, 2026, each adjusted to this home's size and to the market when it sold. Confidence: medium. In a test on the last six months of closings, sets drawn this way came within about 9% of the actual sale price half the time.

In The Peninsula, 9 homes sold in the 24 months to April 13, 2026 at a Median $510,000 ($202/sq ft, all sizes), 98% of list.

Own a home nearby? Ask Grant Hammond what this sale means for its value.

Analysis by Grant Hammond, Compass RE. Figures as of November 15, 2026, from Realtracs closings and listings via IDX and the MLS import.

Own a home near 5137 Bay Overlook Dr?

This home sold for $435,000 on April 13, 2026. Grant Hammond, Compass RE, can show what yours could sell for, from this sale and the other recent closings in The Peninsula.

Get your home's value

Description of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

5137 Bay Overlook Dr is a home built in 1999, with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and 1,999 sq ft.

Listing agent's remarks

Welcome to 5137 Bay Overlook Drive, a beautifully maintained three bedroom, two bathroom home in the heart of Hermitage that offers thoughtful upgrades and true move-in-ready appeal. From the moment you step inside, you?ll notice the care that has gone into enhancing both comfort and long-term value throughout the home. Enjoy year-round outdoor living on the screened-in back porch?the perfect spot for peaceful mornings, relaxing evenings, or gathering with friends. Beneath the home, the crawlspace has been professionally deodorized and upgraded with a new vapor barrier and vents, providing added efficiency and peace of mind. Inside, all three bedrooms feature upgraded luxury vinyl plank flooring, replacing carpet with a clean, modern look that is both stylish and easy to maintain. The secondary full bathroom has been tastefully refreshed with fresh paint, a newly installed concrete countertop, and a sleek sliding glass door for the tub and shower, creating a more elevated, contemporary feel. $2,000 washer/dryer cabinet tower to stay with the home in the laundry room. Gutter guards have also been added for low-maintenance exterior care. Ideally located in Hermitage, this home offers convenient access to shopping, dining, parks, and major commuter routes while still maintaining a comfortable neighborhood setting. If you?ve been searching for a well-cared-for home where the meaningful updates are already complete, this one truly checks all the boxes.

Written by the listing agent and shown as published in Realtracs, via the Realtracs Internet Data Exchange. Grant Hammond has not verified these statements.

Listing brokerage: Compass Tennessee, LLC, 615-475-5616. MLS #3130499. Listings courtesy of Realtracs as distributed by MLS GRID.

Property details for 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

Complete reported fields for 5137 Bay Overlook Dr (reference).

MLS #3130499
StatusSold
Listing brokerageCompass Tennessee, LLC, 615-475-5616
Closing price$435,000
ClosedApril 13, 2026
Last list price$434,900
Price / sq ft at closing$218
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms2
All 17 property fields
Living area1,999 sq ft
Year built1999
HOA dues$15 / mo
SubdivisionThe Peninsula
Original list price$449,900 (February 12, 2026)
PetsPermitted (as listed)
ListedFebruary 12, 2026
UpdatedJune 24, 2026

Sale and price history of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

DateEventPriceChange
Off market
Closed$435,000-$14,900 (-3.3%) vs list
Price change$434,900-$15,000 (-3.3%)
Under contract
Listed$449,900
Deed recorded$431,500
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$166,758
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded

Listed February 12, 2026, this listing was on the market 26 days before it went under contract. It was originally listed at $449,900; the last asking price was $434,900 (-3.3%). It closed on April 13, 2026 for $435,000 (+$100 (+0.0%) against the last list price).

  • Sold for $435,000 (April 13, 2026), about 1% above the prior recorded sale ($431,500, August 30, 2023).
  • County assessment: $429,700 total appraised value (land $103,500 + improvements $326,200).

County assessment from Davidson County public records; listing-cycle history tracked by the GH Market Engine.

County appraisal by year

The county Assessor's appraised value of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr by year: $179,400 in 1999 to $429,700 in 2025, a change of +140%. Appraised value is the county's figure for taxation, not a market value or a sale price.

YearLandBuildingTotal
2025$103,500$326,200$429,700
2021$62,000$230,000$292,000
2017$56,000$198,400$254,400
2013$46,000$146,500$192,500
2009$43,000$147,400$190,400
2005$35,000$166,000$201,000
2001$35,000$145,500$180,500
2000$28,000$0$172,300
1999$28,000$151,400$179,400

Source: county Assessor of Property, historical appraisal record, as recorded; totals are the county's own figures.

The sale in detail

5137 Bay Overlook Dr sold for $435,000 on April 13, 2026, $100 (0.0%) above its last list price of $434,900. This home is no longer for sale; the figures below are the recorded sale, per Realtracs.

Closing price$435,000
Closed
Listed
Under contract
Days on market26 (listing to contract)
Original list price$449,900
Price changes while listed1
Last list price$434,900
Sale to list price100.0%
Prior recorded sale$431,500 ()
Change since the prior sale+1% (+0.3% a year, unadjusted)
Area median days on market (12 mo)25 days, Hermitage 37076 (336 closings)
County appraised value$429,700
Sale vs. appraised value+1%
Price per sq ft at closing$218
HOA dues (as listed)$15 / mo

Closing price and date per Realtracs via IDX. Not an estimate of current value.

How this home is priced

The 5 comparable sales within 0.9 miles, closed October 30, 2025 to March 31, 2026
AddressBedsSq ftDistanceSold forClosed
5112 Bay Overlook Dr42,2720.1 mi$476,160February 2, 2026
4804 Mara Vista32,0140.3 mi$445,000March 27, 2026
6517 Lampe Ct32,0960.8 mi$469,500March 31, 2026
5012 John Hagar Rd31,9380.5 mi$460,000December 10, 2025
321 Moonwater Ct32,1860.2 mi$485,000October 30, 2025
Sold in The Peninsula, 24 months to April 13, 2026
9 homes; Median price $510,000; Median $202/sq ft (9 with a size); 98% of list; Median 24 days on market

Location of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

5137 Bay Overlook Dr sits in The Peninsula, Hermitage.

Approximately 11 miles from downtown Nashville (straight-line distance).

Official records for 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

Sales and listings similar to 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

Frequently asked questions about 5137 Bay Overlook Dr

Is 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage still for sale?

No. 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage sold for $435,000 on April 13, 2026, per Realtracs. Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, about homes for sale nearby.

What did 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage sell for?

$435,000, closing on April 13, 2026, $100 (0.0%) above its last list price of $434,900; about $218 per square foot across 1,999 square feet.

What are the property taxes on 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage?

the county's appraisal roll values it at $429,700 (land $103,500, building $326,200) for 2025.

Did 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage sell above or below the asking price?

Above. It sold for $435,000, $100 (0.0%) above its last list price of $434,900 and 3.3% below its original list price of $449,900, per Realtracs.

What did 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage sell for before?

The prior recorded sale was $431,500 on August 30, 2023 (county records). Earlier recorded sales: $166,758 (August 16, 1999). The 2026 sale was about 1% above the prior sale, roughly 0.3% a year over 2.6 years, not adjusted for renovations or other improvements.

How does the sale of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage compare with similar sales?

Five comparable sales within 0.9 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 15%) sold between October 30, 2025 and March 31, 2026. Adjusted to 5137 Bay Overlook Dr's size and to the market, they put its sale price in line with them. Confidence: medium. In our test on recent closings, sets drawn this way came within about 9% of the actual sale price half the time.

How many homes sold in The Peninsula?

9 homes closed in The Peninsula between April 13, 2024 and April 13, 2026, with a Median price of $510,000 and a Median of $202 per square foot across all sizes; the Median sale took 24 days. Per Realtracs closings and listings.

How does the sale price of 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage compare with its county appraised value?

It sold for $435,000, about 1% above its 2025 county appraisal of $429,700 on the county record.

What were the HOA dues at 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage?

HOA dues were $15 per month, as listed.

How long did 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage take to sell?

26 days on market from listing to contract, in line with the 12-month median of 25 days for Hermitage 37076 home sales (336 closings with a recorded listing period, per Realtracs).

Who owns 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage?

Ownership is a public record kept by the Metro Nashville and Davidson County Assessor of Property, under parcel 097160A06600CO; the record is linked under Official records on this page. This page does not publish owner names.

Who can tell me more about 5137 Bay Overlook Dr, Hermitage?

Grant Hammond, Compass RE (TN Broker), with 25+ years and $1B+ in Middle Tennessee sales. Use the question form on this page.

Ask a questionCallText