Skip to main content
Menu
(615) 945-7123
This home has sold. Ask Grant Hammond about similar Nashville listings.

Sold by October 20, 2026 · $1,500,000

$284/sq ft

4 beds · 3.5 baths · 5,282 sq ft · 0.7 acres

4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville, TN 37216

Single-family home in McGaugheys Haysboro · Built 1953

100.0% of its last list price

MLS #3501219 · listed May 2, 2026 · updated October 20, 2026

Sale record checked .

4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville, TN 37216, a 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath, 5,282 sq ft home in McGaugheys Haysboro, built in 1953, sold for $1,500,000 by October 20, 2026, 100% of its last list price, compared below with 5 comparable sales within 3.7 miles.

4434 Brush Hill Rd sale analysis

4434 Brush Hill Rd, a 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath, 5,282 sq ft home in McGaugheys Haysboro, Nashville, TN 37216, sold by October 20, 2026 for $1,500,000, 100% of its last asking price of $1,500,000 (first listed for $1,924,000), 150 days from listing to contract, per the Realtracs closing.

Its sale price is not judged here. The 5 closest comparable sales within 3.7 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 30%) sold between November 3, 2025 and September 19, 2026, but in a test on recent closings sets drawn this way came within about 18% of the actual sale price only half the time, too wide to judge one home. They are listed below.

In McGaugheys Haysboro, 7 homes sold in the 12 months to October 20, 2026 at a Median $600,000 ($423/sq ft, all sizes), 89.7% of list.

Own a home nearby? Ask Grant Hammond what this sale means for its value.

Analysis by Grant Hammond, Compass RE. Figures as of November 17, 2026, from Realtracs closings and listings via IDX and the MLS import.

Own a home near 4434 Brush Hill Rd?

This home sold for $1,500,000 by October 20, 2026. Grant Hammond, Compass RE, can show what yours could sell for, from this sale and the other recent closings in McGaugheys Haysboro.

Get your home's value

Description of 4434 Brush Hill Rd

4434 Brush Hill Rd is a 2-story Contemporary home built in 1953, with 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and 5,282 sq ft. Listed details include stone construction, a finished basement, 2 garage spaces and river views.

Listing agent's remarks

OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY 9/26. 1-5 pm SUNDAY 9/27 1-4 pm PRIVACY, VIEWS & CONVENIENCE! This beautifully renovated Mid-Century Modern home sits on a gated and fenced .70-acre lot with stunning views of the Cumberland River and a heated, in-ground saltwater pool. Designed for both everyday living and entertaining, the open-concept main level features a dramatic wall of windows that fills the home with natural light and opens to a beautiful new composite deck overlooking the property. The walk-out basement is an entertainer's dream, opening directly to an expansive patio and pool area. Inside, you'll find a wet bar and snack area, pool table and TV seating area, spacious bedroom, full bath, fireplace, gym/oversized theater and media room with potential for a recording studio, plus an additional flex room offering endless possibilities. Major improvements add comfort and peace of mind, including a whole-house Generac generator, three HVAC systems, a new roof installed by Don Kennedy approximately six months ago, and a newly installed pool liner. Enjoy the feeling of a private retreat while being just 10 minutes from downtown Nashville or the airport. A truly unique property offering space, privacy, river views and exceptional entertaining areas, inside and out.

Written by the listing agent and shown as published in Realtracs, via the Realtracs Internet Data Exchange. Grant Hammond has not verified these statements.

Listing brokerage: Benchmark Realty, 931-281-6160. MLS #3501219. Listings courtesy of Realtracs as distributed by MLS GRID.

Property details for 4434 Brush Hill Rd

Complete reported fields for 4434 Brush Hill Rd (reference).

MLS #3501219
StatusSold
Listing brokerageBenchmark Realty, 931-281-6160
Closing price$1,500,000
Closedby October 20, 2026
Last list price$1,500,000
Price / sq ft at closing$284
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3.5 (3 full, 1 half)
All 37 property fields
Living area5,282 sq ft
Lot size0.7 acres
Year built1953
Garage spaces2
Stories2
HeatingNatural Gas, Zoned
BasementExterior Entry, Finished, Full
ConstructionStone
ParkingGarage Door Opener, Attached, Concrete
Annual taxes$10,020
AppliancesGas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Water Purifier
Interior featuresCeiling Fan(s), Central Vacuum, Open Floorplan, Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar
FireplaceYes, per the listing
Architectural styleContemporary
Exterior featuresGas Grill
PoolIn Ground, Private
ViewRiver
WaterfrontYes, per the listing
Water sourcePublic
SewerPublic Sewer
UtilitiesElectricity Available, Natural Gas Available, Water Available
Garage typeAttached Garage
SubdivisionMcGaugheys Haysboro
CountyDavidson
ZoningRS20 · Single-family (20,000 sq ft lot)
Original list price$1,924,000 (May 2, 2026)
ListedMay 2, 2026
Listing last changed by the MLSOctober 20, 2026

Sale and price history of 4434 Brush Hill Rd

DateEventPriceChange
Closed$1,500,000at list
Under contract
Price change$1,500,000-$250,000 (-14.3%)
Price change$1,750,000-$149,000 (-7.8%)
Price change$1,899,000-$25,000 (-1.3%)
Listed$1,924,000
Deed recorded$600,000
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$425,000
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$255,300
Deed recorded$155,315
Deed recorded$152,699
Deed recorded$141,294
Deed recorded$94,500
Deed recorded$32,000

Listed May 2, 2026, this listing was on the market 150 days before it went under contract. It was originally listed at $1,924,000; the last asking price was $1,500,000 (-22.0%). It closed on October 20, 2026 for $1,500,000 at the last list price.

  • Sold for $1,500,000 (October 20, 2026), about 150% above the prior recorded sale ($600,000, November 9, 2012).
  • County assessment: $1,424,300 total appraised value (land $522,000 + improvements $902,300).

County assessment from Davidson County public records; listing-cycle history tracked by the GH Market Engine.

Every listing at this address

4434 Brush Hill Rd has 2 Realtracs listing records in the GH Market Engine archive. Every dated event the engine holds for this address, newest first, with its source.

DateEventPriceSource
by Sold$1,500,000Realtracs MLS #3501219
Pendingn/aRealtracs MLS #3501219
Under contractn/aRealtracs MLS #3501219
Price change$1,500,000Realtracs MLS #3501219
Price change$1,750,000Realtracs MLS #3501219
by Price change$1,899,000Realtracs MLS #3501219
Listing removedn/aRealtracs MLS #3186669
by Price change$1,974,000Realtracs MLS #3186669
by Listed for sale$1,975,000Realtracs MLS #3186669
Listed for sale$1,924,000Realtracs MLS #3501219
Sold (public record)$600,000Public record
Sold (public record)$425,000Public record
Sold (public record)$255,300Public record
Sold (public record)$155,315Public record
Sold (public record)$152,699Public record
Sold (public record)$141,294Public record
Sold (public record)$94,500Public record
Sold (public record)$32,000Public record

Our daily record of these listings starts June 18, 2026; earlier dates come from each listing's own Realtracs record. Recorded sales come from Davidson County public records. "by" marks a date the archive learned after the fact.

County appraisal by year

The Davidson County Assessor's appraised value of 4434 Brush Hill Rd by year: $183,700 in 1999 to $1,424,300 in 2025, a change of +675%. Appraised value is the county's figure for taxation, not a market value or a sale price.

Most of that change is the building's appraised value, $141,600 in 1999 to $875,400 in 2025.

YearLandBuildingYard itemsTotal
2025$522,000$875,400$26,900$1,424,300
2021$194,300$802,700$29,100$1,026,100
2017$154,000$424,300$26,300$604,600
2014$105,000$439,700$20,200$564,900
2013$105,000$345,900$0$450,900
2009$98,000$340,700$0$438,700
2005$63,000$230,300$0$293,300
2001$56,000$174,400$0$230,400
2000$42,100$141,600$0$183,700
1999$42,100$141,600$0$183,700

Source: Davidson County Assessor of Property, historical appraisal record, as recorded; totals are the county's own figures. Davidson County reappraises every four years (most recently 2025); other years reflect changes recorded between reappraisals.

The sale in detail

4434 Brush Hill Rd sold for $1,500,000 by October 20, 2026, at its last list price. This home is no longer for sale; the figures below are the recorded sale, per Realtracs.

Closing price$1,500,000
Closedby
Listed
Under contract
Days on market150 (listing to contract)
Original list price$1,924,000
Price changes while listed3
Last list price$1,500,000
Sale to list price100.0%
Prior recorded sale$600,000 ()
Change since the prior sale+150% (+6.8% a year, unadjusted)
County appraised value$1,424,300
Sale vs. appraised value+5%
Price per sq ft at closing$284

Closing price and date per Realtracs via IDX. Not an estimate of current value.

How this home is priced

The 5 comparable sales within 3.7 miles, closed November 3, 2025 to September 19, 2026
AddressBedsSq ftDistanceSold forClosed
3866 Hutson Ave55,5731.8 mi$1,280,000September 19, 2026
1105 Winding Way43,8000.9 mi$1,599,900March 2, 2026
709 Tahlena Ave54,0441.6 mi$889,000June 30, 2026
1407 Cardinal Ave54,8641.5 mi$1,261,000November 3, 2025
2132 Neelys Bend Rd44,2633.7 mi$827,500July 27, 2026

How the sales are adjusted: each sale price is scaled to this home's size (price × (this home's sq ft ÷ the sale's sq ft)0.7) and moved to the market when it sold with a monthly price index built from 26 months of closings; the middle of the five adjusted values sets the read, so one unusual sale cannot move it far. 1105 Winding Way ($421/sq ft) is well outside the others' price per square foot and is included; the median limits its effect.

Sold in McGaugheys Haysboro, 12 months to October 20, 2026
7 homes; Median price $600,000; Median $423/sq ft (7 with a size); 89.7% of list

Location of 4434 Brush Hill Rd

4434 Brush Hill Rd sits in McGaugheys Haysboro, Nashville, Davidson County.

Approximately 6.4 miles from downtown Nashville (straight-line distance).

Assigned schools

4434 Brush Hill Rd is zoned for Dan Mills Elementary, Isaac Litton Middle, Stratford STEM Magnet School Upper Campus. Attendance zones and enrollment change, confirm current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district before relying on it. Look up the zoned school: MNPS Zone Finder.

Elementary
Dan Mills Elementary
Metro Nashville Public Schools
Middle
Isaac Litton Middle
Metro Nashville Public Schools
High
Stratford STEM Magnet School Upper Campus
Metro Nashville Public Schools

Zoning for 4434 Brush Hill Rd

Zoning: RS20 · Single-family (20,000 sq ft lot). Metro zones this parcel RS20. New not owner-occupied short-term rental permits are not permitted in AR2A, R, RS or RM zoned properties, and an existing permit there may be renewed by its holder but is not transferable if the property is sold, per Metro Codes' short-term rental permit types page (last updated March 13, 2026). An owner who permanently lives on the property, as a person rather than an LLC, corporation or trust, may apply for an owner-occupied permit (one per lot in single- and two-family districts), per the same page. Confirm with Metro Codes before buying.

Sources: Metro Nashville Planning, parcels with zoning, parcel 05116001400, read November 15, 2026; district names from Metro Code 17.08.010; Metro Nashville Codes, short-term rental permit types, last updated March 13, 2026. Nashville STR zoning and permits guide

Official records for 4434 Brush Hill Rd

Sales and listings similar to 4434 Brush Hill Rd

Frequently asked questions about 4434 Brush Hill Rd

Is 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville still for sale?

No. 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville sold for $1,500,000 by October 20, 2026, per Realtracs. Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, about homes for sale nearby.

What did 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville sell for?

$1,500,000, closing by October 20, 2026, at its last list price; about $284 per square foot across 5,282 square feet.

What are the property taxes on 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville?

The listing reports an annual property tax of $10,020. Davidson County's appraisal roll values it at $1,424,300 (land $522,000, building $875,400) for 2025.

Did 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville sell above or below the asking price?

At the asking price: it sold for $1,500,000, its last list price and 22.0% below its original list price of $1,924,000, per Realtracs.

What did 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville sell for before?

The prior recorded sale was $600,000 on November 9, 2012 (county records). Earlier recorded sales: $425,000 (July 12, 2007), $255,300 (October 11, 1996), $155,315 (March 4, 1996). The 2026 sale was about 150% above the prior sale, roughly 6.8% a year over 13.9 years, not adjusted for renovations or other improvements.

How does the sale of 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville compare with similar sales?

Not with confidence. The five closest comparable sales within 3.7 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 30%) sold between November 3, 2025 and September 19, 2026, but in our test on recent closings sets drawn this way came within about 18% of the actual sale price only half the time, too wide to judge one home's price.

How many homes sold in McGaugheys Haysboro?

7 homes closed in McGaugheys Haysboro between October 20, 2025 and October 20, 2026, with a Median price of $600,000 and a Median of $423 per square foot across all sizes. Per Realtracs closings and listings.

How does the sale price of 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville compare with its county appraised value?

It sold for $1,500,000, about 5% above its 2025 county appraisal of $1,424,300 on the Davidson County record.

What schools is 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville zoned for?

4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville is zoned for Dan Mills Elementary, Isaac Litton Middle, Stratford STEM Magnet School Upper Campus. Attendance zones and enrollment change, verify current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district.

Who owns 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville?

Ownership is a public record kept by the Metro Nashville and Davidson County Assessor of Property, under parcel 05116001400; the record is linked under Official records on this page. This page does not publish owner names.

How do I find homes for sale near 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville?

Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, through the form on this page or call or text (615) 945-7123; he can send active listings and recent sales in McGaugheys Haysboro as they come up.

Who can tell me more about 4434 Brush Hill Rd, Nashville?

Grant Hammond, Compass RE (TN Broker), with 25+ years and $1B+ in Middle Tennessee sales and hundreds of millions in luxury closings. Use the question form on this page.

Ask a questionCallText