Skip to main content
Menu
(615) 945-7123

For sale · $1,295,000

$351/sq ft

4 beds · 4 baths · 3,692 sq ft · 1.66 acres

5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville, TN 37220

Single-family home in Anderson Heights · Built 1970

MLS #3632374 · listed November 4, 2026 · 15 days on market · updated November 4, 2026

Listing details checked .

5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville, TN 37220, is a 4-bedroom, 4-bath, 3,692 sq ft home in Anderson Heights, built in 1970, for sale at $1,295,000 ($351/sq ft), compared below with 5 comparable sales within 1.4 miles; first listed at $1,325,000 on August 4, 2026, then relisted November 4, 2026.

Is 5161 Granny White Pike priced right? The quick read

5161 Granny White Pike is a 4-bedroom, 4-bath, 3,692 sq ft home in Anderson Heights, Nashville, TN 37220, offered at $1,295,000 ($351/sq ft); its last recorded sale was $690,000 on October 2, 2024.

Its asking price is not judged here. The 5 closest comparable sales within 1.4 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 20%) sold between January 14, 2026 and June 25, 2026, but in a test on recent closings sets drawn this way came within about 13% of the actual sale price only half the time, too wide to judge one home. They are listed below. It last sold for $690,000 on December 3, 2024, per Realtracs.

At this address: first listed on August 4, 2026 at $1,325,000 (MLS #3335294), then relisted November 4, 2026 at $1,295,000 (MLS #3632374). 106 days on the market across 2 listings, 14 on this one.

In ZIP 37220 (Nashville), 168 homes sold in the 12 months to November 18, 2026 at a Median $867,500 ($387/sq ft, all sizes), 97.5% of list. 58 are for sale there now, about 4.1 months of supply at 14 sales a month.

All-in, about $8,503/mo at 20% down (7.50% 30-year fixed).

School zone: assigned to Percy Priest Elementary, John Trotwood Moore Middle, Hillsboro Comp High School. Attendance zones can change; verify current assignment with the district.

Next step: ask Grant Hammond about 5161 Granny White Pike: comparable sales, HOA, a tour. He replies personally.

Analysis by Grant Hammond, Compass RE. Figures as of November 18, 2026, from Realtracs closings and listings via IDX and the MLS import.

Description of 5161 Granny White Pike

5161 Granny White Pike is a 2-story home built in 1970, with 4 bedrooms, 4 baths and 3,692 sq ft. Listed details include brick construction and 2 garage spaces.

Listing agent's remarks

OWNER FINANCING AVALIABLE less than bank rate 10% down minimum. Discover a rare Forest Hills retreat at 5161 Granny White Pike, ideally positioned beside Radnor Lake and surrounded by the natural beauty that defines this prestigious Nashville community. Set on approximately 1.66 acres, the home's elevated setting provides beautiful treetop views, privacy, and a peaceful atmosphere conveniently located between Green Hills and Brentwood. Expansive windows fill the interior with natural light and frame the wooded surroundings, while the inviting wraparound porch offers the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee, entertain guests, or unwind at the end of the day. Inside, the spacious residence features 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and 3,692 square feet, providing plenty of room for comfortable everyday living, working from home, and hosting family and friends. Enjoy the serenity of a nature-filled setting without sacrificing convenience. The home is ideally located between Green Hills and Brentwood, with easy access to shopping, dining, schools, parks, and major Nashville destinations. Tucked into the welcoming Forest Hills community, the property offers a quiet residential feel while remaining close to everything the city has to offer. Nearby school information includes the highly rated Percy Priest Elementary. 5161 Granny White Pike offers the perfect combination of space, privacy, convenience, and connection to nature, a peaceful refuge in one of Nashville's most desirable locations.

Written by the listing agent and shown as published in Realtracs, via the Realtracs Internet Data Exchange. Grant Hammond has not verified these statements.

Listing brokerage: Realty Of America, LLC. MLS #3632374. Listings courtesy of Realtracs as distributed by MLS GRID.

Property details for 5161 Granny White Pike

Complete reported fields for 5161 Granny White Pike (reference).

MLS #3632374
StatusActive
Listing brokerageRealty Of America, LLC
Price$1,295,000
Price / sq ft$351
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms4
Living area3,692 sq ft
Lot size1.66 acres
All 28 property fields
Year built1970
Garage spaces2
Stories2
HeatingCentral
BasementNone
ConstructionBrick
ParkingGarage Door Opener, Attached
Annual taxes$8,483
AppliancesBuilt-In Electric Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Electric Oven, Microwave, OVEN, Range, Refrigerator
Water sourcePublic
SewerPublic Sewer
UtilitiesWater Available
Garage typeAttached Garage
SubdivisionAnderson Heights
CountyDavidson
Original list price$1,295,000 (November 4, 2026)
ListedNovember 4, 2026
Days on market15
Listing last changed by the MLSNovember 4, 2026

Price history of 5161 Granny White Pike

DateEventPrice
Listed$1,295,000
Deed recorded$690,000
Deed recorded$555,000
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$319,800
Deed recorded$270,000
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$155,400
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Quitclaim deedNo price recorded
Deed recorded$157,500
Deed recorded$101,306

Listed November 4, 2026, this listing has been on the market 15 days as of November 19, 2026. The asking price has not changed since it was relisted on November 4, 2026.

  • Listed at $1,295,000, about 88% above the last recorded sale ($690,000, October 2, 2024).
  • County assessment: $1,219,700 total appraised value (land $712,500 + improvements $507,200).
  • Land accounts for about 58% of the county appraised value, a land-weighted parcel (renovation or rebuild potential; verify zoning and utilities before relying on it).

County assessment from Davidson County public records; listing-cycle history tracked by the GH Market Engine.

Every listing at this address

5161 Granny White Pike has 3 Realtracs listing records in the GH Market Engine archive. Every dated event the engine holds for this address, newest first, with its source.

DateEventPriceSource
Listing removedn/aRealtracs MLS #3335294
Listed for sale$1,295,000Realtracs MLS #3632374
Price change$1,295,000Realtracs MLS #3335294
Listed for sale$1,325,000Realtracs MLS #3335294
Sold$690,000Realtracs MLS #2664467
by Price change$775,000Realtracs MLS #2664467
Sold (public record)$690,000Public record
Under contractn/aRealtracs MLS #2664467
Listing removedn/aRealtracs MLS #2664467
Listed for sale$990,000Realtracs MLS #2664467
Sold (public record)$555,000Public record
Sold (public record)$319,800Public record
Sold (public record)$270,000Public record
Sold (public record)$155,400Public record
Sold (public record)$157,500Public record
Sold (public record)$101,306Public record

Our daily record of these listings starts December 3, 2024; earlier dates come from each listing's own Realtracs record. Recorded sales come from Davidson County public records. "by" marks a date the archive learned after the fact.

County appraisal by year

The Davidson County Assessor's appraised value of 5161 Granny White Pike by year: $195,000 in 1999 to $1,219,700 in 2025, a change of +525%. Appraised value is the county's figure for taxation, not a market value or a sale price.

43% of that change is the building's appraised value, $70,000 in 1999 to $507,200 in 2025.

YearLandBuildingTotal
2025$712,500$507,200$1,219,700
2021$461,700$189,400$651,100
2020$359,100$189,900$549,000
2017$359,100$225,100$584,200
2013$315,000$104,400$419,400
2009$315,000$108,700$423,700
2005$165,000$174,300$339,300
2002$150,000$120,000$270,000
2001$150,000$135,500$285,500
2000$125,000$70,000$195,000
1999$125,000$70,000$195,000

Source: Davidson County Assessor of Property, historical appraisal record, as recorded; totals are the county's own figures. Davidson County reappraises every four years (most recently 2025); other years reflect changes recorded between reappraisals.

What 5161 Granny White Pike costs to own

Estimated monthly ownership for 5161 Granny White Pike at $1,295,000: principal & interest, property tax, insurance. Estimate only; not a loan offer.

List price$1,295,000
Property tax basisThe annual bill reported in the listing, $8,483, which agrees with the Davidson County appraisal for 2025 of $1,219,700 × 25% (the Tennessee residential assessment ratio) × the Davidson County General Services District rate

Financing 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville

Estimated total monthly payment for 5161 Granny White Pike is about $8,503/mo, 20% down on a 30-year fixed at 7.50% (a jumbo loan), including principal & interest $7,244, property tax $707, homeowners insurance $552. Estimate only; not a loan offer.

Principal & interest$7,244/mo
Property tax$707/mo
Homeowners insurance (est.)$552/mo
Estimated total$8,503/mo

Assumes 20% down, 30-year fixed at 7.50% (Mortgage News Daily, as of November 18, 2026). Rate source: Mortgage News Daily, jumbo 30-year fixed index. Homeowners insurance is estimated by home value from Insurify's published Nashville averages (checked September 6, 2026); a quote for this property will differ. Property tax: the annual bill reported in the listing, $8,483, which agrees with the Davidson County appraisal for 2025 of $1,219,700 × 25% (the Tennessee residential assessment ratio) × the Davidson County General Services District rate. Estimate only; not a loan offer or appraisal. Enable JavaScript to adjust down payment, term, loan type, and rate.

How the rate moves this payment

30-year ratePrincipal & interestEst. total / movs current
6.50%$6,548/mo$7,807/mo-$696/mo
7.00%$6,893/mo$8,152/mo-$351/mo
7.50%$7,244/mo$8,503/mocurrent
8.00%$7,602/mo$8,861/mo+$358/mo
8.50%$7,966/mo$9,225/mo+$722/mo

Principal & interest on a 30-year fixed at 20% down ($1,036,000 loan), with property tax, insurance held constant at $1,259/mo. Current 30-year fixed 7.50% (Mortgage News Daily, as of November 18, 2026). Estimate only; not a loan offer.

Buy versus rent, 5161 Granny White Pike

Owning 5161 Granny White Pike runs about $8,503/mo all-in, from the payment estimate above. Whether buying beats renting turns on how long you stay, how fast prices and rents move, and the rent you would otherwise pay. Turn on JavaScript to model those assumptions and find the year buying pulls ahead.

Method: net cost to own equals down payment plus about 3% closing plus payments made, minus equity built (principal paid and appreciation) and about 7% exit costs, measured against cumulative rent. Broker commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. Estimate only; not financial advice.

How this home is priced

The 5 comparable sales within 1.4 miles, closed January 14, 2026 to June 25, 2026
AddressBedsSq ftDistanceSold forClosed
1000 Norfleet Dr43,9850.8 mi$1,850,000June 25, 2026
1206 Mcgrace Ln34,4000.1 mi$1,750,000June 1, 2026
5308 Otter Creek Ct44,0050.5 mi$1,175,000June 18, 2026
5212 Shenandoah Court43,3930.6 mi$1,120,000January 14, 2026
508 Battery Dr43,1151.4 mi$1,150,000May 14, 2026

How the sales are adjusted: each sale price is scaled to this home's size (price × (this home's sq ft ÷ the sale's sq ft)0.7) and moved to today's market with a monthly price index built from 26 months of closings; the middle of the five adjusted values sets the read, so one unusual sale cannot move it far.

Sold in ZIP 37220 (Nashville), 12 months to November 18, 2026
168 homes; Median price $867,500; Median $387/sq ft (99 with a size); 97.5% of list; Median 28 days on market
For sale in ZIP 37220 (Nashville), November 18, 2026
58 listings; Median asking $439/sq ft; at $351/sq ft this listing asks more than 26% of them
Pace
14 sales a month over 12 months against 58 for sale: about 4.1 months of supply. Days on market counts only the 168 that sold; months of supply counts the 58 for sale now

Location of 5161 Granny White Pike

5161 Granny White Pike sits in Anderson Heights, Nashville, Davidson County.

Approximately 6.5 miles from downtown Nashville (straight-line distance).

Assigned schools

5161 Granny White Pike is zoned for Percy Priest Elementary, John Trotwood Moore Middle, Hillsboro Comp High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, confirm current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district before relying on it. Look up the zoned school: MNPS Zone Finder.

Elementary
Percy Priest Elementary
Metro Nashville Public Schools
Middle
John Trotwood Moore Middle
Metro Nashville Public Schools
High
Hillsboro Comp High School
Metro Nashville Public Schools

Zoning for 5161 Granny White Pike

Zoning here is set by the city, not Metro Nashville; this page does not report it. Confirm the zoning with the city before buying.

Official records for 5161 Granny White Pike

Flood zone

FEMA flood zone X: an area of minimal flood hazard. It is on FEMA flood map panel 47037C0358H, effective April 5, 2017. Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, read November 13, 2026. Confirm the current designation and any insurance requirement with FEMA and a licensed insurer before relying on it. See FEMA's flood map for this address.

Listings similar to 5161 Granny White Pike

Frequently asked questions about 5161 Granny White Pike

Is 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville still for sale?

Yes. As of the latest update (November 18, 2026), 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville is for sale, per Realtracs. Contact Grant Hammond, Compass RE, for current availability.

How much does 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville cost?

5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville is listed at $1,295,000, about $351 per square foot across 3,692 square feet.

Has the price of 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville changed?

Not on this listing; the address was listed before at another price. This listing (MLS #3632374) has been offered at $1,295,000 since it was listed on November 4, 2026, per Realtracs. The address was listed before: on August 4, 2026 at $1,325,000 under MLS #3335294.

Is 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville priced right?

Not with confidence. The five closest comparable sales within 1.4 miles (bedrooms within one, living area within 20%) sold between January 14, 2026 and June 25, 2026, but in our test on recent closings sets drawn this way came within about 13% of the actual sale price only half the time, too wide to judge one home's price. It last sold for $690,000 on December 3, 2024, per Realtracs.

How is the market in ZIP 37220 (Nashville)?

168 homes closed in ZIP 37220 (Nashville) between November 18, 2025 and November 18, 2026, with a Median price of $867,500 and a Median of $387 per square foot across all sizes; the Median sale took 28 days. On November 18, 2026, 58 were for sale, about 4.1 months of supply at the past year's pace. Per Realtracs closings and listings.

What is the estimated monthly payment for 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville?

About $8,503 a month with 20% down on a 30-year fixed at 7.50%, principal and interest $7,244, property tax $707, insurance $552. Estimate only; not a loan offer. Adjust the down payment, term, loan type, and rate in the financing calculator on this page.

What are the property taxes on 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville?

The listing reports an annual property tax of $8,483. Davidson County's appraisal roll values it at $1,219,700 (land $712,500, building $507,200) for 2025. The payment estimate on this page uses $8,483 a year: the annual bill reported in the listing, $8,483, which agrees with the Davidson County appraisal for 2025 of $1,219,700 × 25% (the Tennessee residential assessment ratio) × the Davidson County General Services District rate.

Is 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville in a flood zone?

It is mapped outside FEMA's high-risk area: flood zone X, an area of minimal flood hazard, at the point FEMA's map returns for this address. Part of a lot can map differently, especially near water. FEMA flood map panel 47037C0358H, effective April 5, 2017. Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, read November 13, 2026; confirm with FEMA and a licensed insurer before relying on it.

Who owns 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville?

Ownership is a public record kept by the Metro Nashville and Davidson County Assessor of Property, under parcel 14507003500; the record is linked under Official records on this page. This page does not publish owner names.

What schools is 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville zoned for?

5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville is zoned for Percy Priest Elementary, John Trotwood Moore Middle, Hillsboro Comp High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, verify current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district.

How do I tour or make an offer on 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville?

Request a time using the tour form on this page (in-person or a live video walkthrough), or call or text Grant Hammond, Compass RE, at (615) 945-7123. Grant replies, usually the same day, and confirms the time with the listing agent. Grant Hammond, Compass RE, can prepare and present your offer, walk you through price, contingencies, and timeline, and represent you through closing. Start with the form on this page or call (615) 945-7123. Broker fees are not set by law and are fully negotiable.

Who can tell me more about 5161 Granny White Pike, Nashville?

Grant Hammond, Compass RE (TN Broker), with 25+ years and $1B+ in Middle Tennessee sales and hundreds of millions in luxury closings. Use the tour or question form on this page.

Request a tourAsk a questionCallText