Skip to main content
Menu
(615) 945-7123
This home has sold. Ask Grant Hammond about similar Nolensville listings.

Sold by November 5, 2026 · $684,900

$271/sq ft

4 beds · 3 baths · 2,528 sq ft · 0.21 acres

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville, TN 37135

Single-family home in Bent Creek Ph4 Sec1c · Built 2014

97.9% of its last list price In line with 5 comparable sales within 0.6 miles

MLS #3515112 · listed August 11, 2026 · updated November 5, 2026

Sale record checked .

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville, TN 37135, a 4-bedroom, 3-bath, 2,528 sq ft home in Bent Creek Ph4 Sec1c, built in 2014, sold for $684,900 by November 5, 2026, 97.9% of its last list price, in line with 5 comparable sales within 0.6 miles.

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl sale analysis

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, a 4-bedroom, 3-bath, 2,528 sq ft home in Bent Creek Ph4 Sec1c, Nolensville, TN 37135, sold by November 5, 2026 for $684,900, 97.9% of its last asking price of $699,900 (first listed for $715,000), 53 days from listing to contract, per the Realtracs closing.

It sold in line with 5 comparable sales within 0.6 miles (the same bedrooms, living area within 15%) that sold between July 17, 2026 and October 15, 2026, each adjusted to this home's size and to the market when it sold. Confidence: medium. In a test on the last six months of closings, sets drawn this way came within about 9% of the actual sale price half the time.

In ZIP 37135 (Nolensville), 448 homes sold in the 12 months to November 5, 2026 at a Median $817,500 ($292/sq ft, all sizes), 98.8% of list.

Own a home nearby? Ask Grant Hammond what this sale means for its value.

Analysis by Grant Hammond, Compass RE. Figures as of November 16, 2026, from Realtracs closings and listings via IDX and the MLS import.

Own a home near 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl?

This home sold for $684,900 by November 5, 2026. Grant Hammond, Compass RE, can show what yours could sell for, from this sale and the other recent closings in Bent Creek Ph4 Sec1c.

Get your home's value

Description of 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl is a 2-story Traditional home built in 2014, with 4 bedrooms, 3 baths and 2,528 sq ft. Listed details include brick and fiber cement construction, a crawl-space foundation and 2 garage spaces.

Listing agent's remarks

Welcome to this beautiful Nolensville home situated on a level lot with a fenced-in backyard and covered deck, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. A charming large front porch welcomes you into the home, which features 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths. The large kitchen has stainless steal appliances, beautiful cabinetry, granite counters and hard wood floors throughout the main living except the bedroom, dining room. The spacious primary suite is conveniently located upstairs, while the main level offers a bedroom and full bath complete with a Murphy bed, providing flexible space for guests, an office, or a playroom. The home also offers a large two-car garage and plenty of functional living space throughout. With its inviting outdoor spaces, versatile floor plan, and desirable Nolensville location, this home is a wonderful place to call home!

Written by the listing agent and shown as published in Realtracs, via the Realtracs Internet Data Exchange. Grant Hammond has not verified these statements.

Listing brokerage: Crye-Leike, Inc., REALTORS, 615-771-6620. MLS #3515112. Listings courtesy of Realtracs as distributed by MLS GRID.

Property details for 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

Complete reported fields for 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl (reference).

MLS #3515112
StatusSold
Listing brokerageCrye-Leike, Inc., REALTORS, 615-771-6620
Closing price$684,900
Closedby November 5, 2026
Last list price$699,900
Price / sq ft at closing$271
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
All 34 property fields
Living area2,528 sq ft
Lot size0.21 acres
Year built2014
Garage spaces2
Stories2
HeatingCentral, Fireplace Insert, Natural Gas
BasementCrawl Space
ConstructionBrick, Fiber Cement
ParkingGarage Door Opener, Garage Faces Front, Driveway, Attached
Annual taxes$2,886
AppliancesDishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Electric Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
Interior featuresCeiling Fan(s), Entrance Foyer, Open Floorplan, Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s)
FireplaceYes, per the listing
Architectural styleTraditional
Water sourcePublic
SewerPublic Sewer
UtilitiesElectricity Available, Natural Gas Available, Water Available, Underground Utilities
Garage typeAttached Garage
HOA dues$85 / mo
SubdivisionBent Creek Ph4 Sec1c
CountyWilliamson
Original list price$715,000 (August 11, 2026)
HOA dues includeMaintenance Grounds
ListedAugust 11, 2026
Listing last changed by the MLSNovember 5, 2026

Sale and price history of 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

DateEventPriceChange
Closed$684,900-$15,000 (-2.1%) vs list
Under contract
Price change$699,900-$15,100 (-2.1%)
Listed$715,000
Deed recorded$750,000

Listed August 11, 2026, this listing was on the market 53 days before it went under contract. It was originally listed at $715,000; the last asking price was $699,900 (-2.1%). It closed on November 5, 2026 for $684,900 (-$15,000 (-2.1%) against the last list price).

  • Sold for $684,900 (November 5, 2026), about 9% below the prior recorded sale ($750,000, May 24, 2022).
  • County assessment: $449,600 total appraised value (land $100,000 + improvements $349,600).

County assessment from Williamson County public records; listing-cycle history tracked by the GH Market Engine.

Every listing at this address

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl has 2 Realtracs listing records in the GH Market Engine archive. Every dated event the engine holds for this address, newest first, with its source.

DateEventPriceSource
by Sold$684,900Realtracs MLS #3515112
Pendingn/aRealtracs MLS #3515112
Under contractn/aRealtracs MLS #3515112
Price change$699,900Realtracs MLS #3515112
Listed for sale$715,000Realtracs MLS #3515112
Listing removedn/aRealtracs MLS #3178909
by Listed for sale$749,900Realtracs MLS #3178909
Sold (public record)$750,000Public record

Our daily record of these listings starts June 18, 2026; earlier dates come from each listing's own Realtracs record. Recorded sales come from Williamson County public records. "by" marks a date the archive learned after the fact.

The sale in detail

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl sold for $684,900 by November 5, 2026, $15,000 (2.1%) below its last list price of $699,900. This home is no longer for sale; the figures below are the recorded sale, per Realtracs.

Closing price$684,900
Closedby
Listed
Under contract
Days on market53 (listing to contract)
Original list price$715,000
Price changes while listed1
Last list price$699,900
Sale to list price97.9%
Prior recorded sale$750,000 ()
Change since the prior sale-9% (-2.0% a year, unadjusted)
Area median days on market (12 mo)33 days, Nolensville 37135 (251 closings)
County appraised value$449,600
Sale vs. appraised value+52%
Price per sq ft at closing$271
HOA dues (as listed)$85 / mo

Closing price and date per Realtracs via IDX. Not an estimate of current value.

How this home is priced

The 5 comparable sales within 0.6 miles, closed July 17, 2026 to October 15, 2026
AddressBedsSq ftDistanceSold forClosed
5963 Fishing Creek Rd42,6840.1 mi$715,500October 15, 2026
5971 Fishing Creek Rd42,6420.1 mi$700,000July 17, 2026
4528 Sawmill Pl42,7600.4 mi$695,000September 3, 2026
2104 Sister Ct42,4180.6 mi$685,000September 9, 2026
2032 Delaware Dr42,9000.6 mi$753,000September 30, 2026

How the sales are adjusted: each sale price is scaled to this home's size (price × (this home's sq ft ÷ the sale's sq ft)0.7) and moved to the market when it sold with a monthly price index built from 26 months of closings; the middle of the five adjusted values sets the read, so one unusual sale cannot move it far.

Sold in ZIP 37135 (Nolensville), 12 months to November 5, 2026
448 homes; Median price $817,500; Median $292/sq ft (401 with a size); 98.8% of list; Median 33 days on market

Home prices by high-school zone in Williamson County

Median list price per square foot for active single-family homes by high-school attendance zone. Attendance zones cross city mailing lines; this is a price comparison, not a rating.

High-school zoneMedian $/sq ft
Brentwood$367/sq ft
Ravenwood$351/sq ft
Franklin$349/sq ft
Independence$338/sq ft
Fred J. Page$327/sq ft
Centennial$306/sq ft
Nolensville (this home)$300/sq ft
Summit$271/sq ft
Fairview$261/sq ft

Computed by Grant Hammond from active Williamson County listings (Realtracs via IDX).

Location of 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl sits in Bent Creek Ph4 Sec1c, Nolensville, Williamson County.

Approximately 16 miles from downtown Nashville (straight-line distance).

Assigned schools

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl is zoned for Mill Creek Elementary School, Mill Creek Middle School, Nolensville High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, confirm current zoning with the Williamson County Schools district before relying on it. Look up the zoned school: Williamson County Schools zones.

Elementary
Mill Creek Elementary School
Williamson County Schools
Middle
Mill Creek Middle School
Williamson County Schools
High
Nolensville High School
Williamson County Schools

Official records for 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

Sales and listings similar to 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

Frequently asked questions about 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl

Is 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville still for sale?

No. 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville sold for $684,900 by November 5, 2026, per Realtracs. Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, about homes for sale nearby.

What did 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville sell for?

$684,900, closing by November 5, 2026, $15,000 (2.1%) below its last list price of $699,900; about $271 per square foot across 2,528 square feet.

What are the property taxes on 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville?

The listing reports an annual property tax of $2,886. Williamson County's appraisal roll values it at $449,600 (land $100,000, building $349,600).

Did 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville sell above or below the asking price?

Below. It sold for $684,900, $15,000 (2.1%) below its last list price of $699,900 and 4.2% below its original list price of $715,000, per Realtracs.

What did 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville sell for before?

The prior recorded sale was $750,000 on May 24, 2022 (county records). The 2026 sale was about 9% below the prior sale, roughly 2.0% a year over 4.5 years, not adjusted for renovations or other improvements.

How does the sale of 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville compare with similar sales?

Five comparable sales within 0.6 miles (the same bedrooms, living area within 15%) sold between July 17, 2026 and October 15, 2026. Adjusted to 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl's size and to the market, they put its sale price in line with them. Confidence: medium. In our test on recent closings, sets drawn this way came within about 9% of the actual sale price half the time.

How many homes sold in ZIP 37135 (Nolensville)?

448 homes closed in ZIP 37135 (Nolensville) between November 5, 2025 and November 5, 2026, with a Median price of $817,500 and a Median of $292 per square foot across all sizes; the Median sale took 33 days. Per Realtracs closings and listings.

How does the sale price of 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville compare with its county appraised value?

It sold for $684,900, about 52% above its $449,600 county appraised value on the Williamson County record.

What were the HOA dues at 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville?

HOA dues were $85 per month, as listed.

How long did 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville take to sell?

53 days on market from listing to contract, longer than the 12-month median of 33 days for Nolensville 37135 home sales (251 closings with a recorded listing period, per Realtracs).

What schools is 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville zoned for?

5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville is zoned for Mill Creek Elementary School, Mill Creek Middle School, Nolensville High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, verify current zoning with the Williamson County Schools district.

Who owns 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville?

Ownership is a public record kept by the Williamson County Assessor of Property, under parcel 059B D 00300 000; the record is linked under Official records on this page. This page does not publish owner names.

Who can tell me more about 5091 Aunt Nannies Pl, Nolensville?

Grant Hammond, Compass RE (TN Broker), with 25+ years and $1B+ in Middle Tennessee sales. Use the question form on this page.

Ask a questionCallText