Skip to main content
Menu
(615) 945-7123
This home has sold. Ask Grant Hammond about similar Nashville listings.

Sold by July 16, 2026 · $255,000

$284/sq ft

2 beds · 1 bath · 899 sq ft · 0.18 acres

5916 Carl Pl, Nashville, TN 37209

Single-family home in West Park · Built 1955

91.1% of its last list price

MLS #3185657 · listed April 29, 2026 · updated August 14, 2026

Sale record checked .

5916 Carl Pl, Nashville, TN 37209, a 2-bedroom, 1-bath, 899 sq ft home in West Park, built in 1955, sold for $255,000 by July 16, 2026, 91.1% of its last list price, compared below with 5 comparable sales within half a mile.

5916 Carl Pl sale analysis

5916 Carl Pl, a 2-bedroom, 1-bath, 899 sq ft home in West Park, Nashville, TN 37209, sold by July 16, 2026 for $255,000, 91.1% of its last asking price of $280,000, 19 days from listing to contract, per the Realtracs closing.

The five closest comparable sales range from $252 to $412 per square foot, too wide a spread for a single verdict. The five closest comparable sales within half a mile (bedrooms within one, living area within 15%) sold between January 14, 2026 and July 2, 2026; they are listed below.

In West Park, 5 homes sold in the 12 months to July 16, 2026 at a Median $370,000 ($355/sq ft, all sizes), 100% of list.

Own a home nearby? Ask Grant Hammond what this sale means for its value.

Analysis by Grant Hammond, Compass RE. Figures as of November 18, 2026, from Realtracs closings and listings via IDX and the MLS import.

Own a home near 5916 Carl Pl?

This home sold for $255,000 by July 16, 2026. Grant Hammond, Compass RE, can show what yours could sell for, from this sale and the other recent closings in West Park.

Get your home's value

Description of 5916 Carl Pl

5916 Carl Pl is a 1-story home built in 1955, with 2 bedrooms, 1 bath and 899 sq ft.

Listing agent's remarks

Builders - let's go! This area is booming with new construction. This lot is ready to become your next project! Back on for the moment so bring over an offer quick!

Written by the listing agent and shown as published in Realtracs, via the Realtracs Internet Data Exchange. Grant Hammond has not verified these statements.

Listing brokerage: Fridrich & Clark Realty, 615-263-4800. MLS #3185657. Listings courtesy of Realtracs as distributed by MLS GRID.

Property details for 5916 Carl Pl

Complete reported fields for 5916 Carl Pl (reference).

MLS #3185657
StatusSold
Listing brokerageFridrich & Clark Realty, 615-263-4800
Closing price$255,000
Closedby July 16, 2026
Last list price$280,000
Price / sq ft at closing$284
Bedrooms2
Bathrooms1
All 22 property fields
Living area899 sq ft
Lot size0.18 acres
Year built1955
Stories1
HeatingCentral
BasementNone
ConstructionFrame
Annual taxes$2,028
SubdivisionWest Park
CountyDavidson
Original list price$280,000 (April 29, 2026)
ListedApril 29, 2026
Listing last changed by the MLSAugust 14, 2026

Sale and price history of 5916 Carl Pl

DateEventPriceChange
Closed$255,000-$25,000 (-8.9%) vs list
Deed recorded$255,000
Under contract
Listed$280,000

Listed April 29, 2026, this listing was on the market 19 days before it went under contract. It closed on July 16, 2026 for $255,000 (-$25,000 (-8.9%) against the last list price).

  • County assessment: $288,300 total appraised value (land $200,000 + improvements $88,300).
  • Land accounts for about 69% of the county appraised value, a land-weighted parcel (renovation or rebuild potential; verify zoning and utilities before relying on it).

County assessment from Davidson County public records; listing-cycle history tracked by the GH Market Engine.

The sale in detail

5916 Carl Pl sold for $255,000 by July 16, 2026, $25,000 (8.9%) below its last list price of $280,000. This home is no longer for sale; the figures below are the recorded sale, per Realtracs.

Closing price$255,000
Closedby
Listed
Under contract
Days on market19 (listing to contract)
Last list price$280,000
Sale to list price91.1%
County appraised value$288,300
Sale vs. appraised value-12%
Price per sq ft at closing$284

Closing price and date per Realtracs via IDX. Not an estimate of current value.

How this home is priced

The 5 comparable sales within half a mile, closed January 14, 2026 to July 2, 2026
AddressBedsSq ftDistanceSold forClosed
5920 Carl Pl3899under 0.1 mi$370,000January 14, 2026
5803 Couch Dr27810.1 mi$314,000July 2, 2026
5805 Couch Dr27810.1 mi$318,500April 13, 2026
5813 Leslie Ave28700.3 mi$219,500March 20, 2026
1504 62nd Ave N28000.4 mi$250,000May 8, 2026

How the sales are adjusted: each sale price is scaled to this home's size (price × (this home's sq ft ÷ the sale's sq ft)0.7) and moved to the market when it sold with a monthly price index built from 26 months of closings; the middle of the five adjusted values sets the read, so one unusual sale cannot move it far. 5813 Leslie Ave ($252/sq ft) is well outside the others' price per square foot and is included; the median limits its effect.

Sold in West Park, 12 months to July 16, 2026
5 homes; Median price $370,000; Median $355/sq ft (5 with a size); 100% of list

Location of 5916 Carl Pl

5916 Carl Pl sits in West Park, Nashville, Davidson County.

Approximately 4.4 miles from downtown Nashville (straight-line distance).

Assigned schools

5916 Carl Pl is zoned for Cockrill Elementary, Moses McKissack Middle, Pearl Cohn Magnet High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, confirm current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district before relying on it. Look up the zoned school: MNPS Zone Finder.

Elementary
Cockrill Elementary
Metro Nashville Public Schools
Middle
Moses McKissack Middle
Metro Nashville Public Schools
High
Pearl Cohn Magnet High School
Metro Nashville Public Schools

Official records for 5916 Carl Pl

Sales and listings similar to 5916 Carl Pl

Frequently asked questions about 5916 Carl Pl

Is 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville still for sale?

No. 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville sold for $255,000 by July 16, 2026, per Realtracs. Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, about homes for sale nearby.

What did 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville sell for?

$255,000, closing by July 16, 2026, $25,000 (8.9%) below its last list price of $280,000; about $284 per square foot across 899 square feet.

What are the property taxes on 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville?

The listing reports an annual property tax of $2,028. Davidson County's appraisal roll values it at $288,300 (land $200,000, building $88,300).

Did 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville sell above or below the asking price?

Below. It sold for $255,000, $25,000 (8.9%) below its last list price of $280,000, per Realtracs.

How does the sale of 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville compare with similar sales?

The five closest comparable sales range from $252 to $412 per square foot, too wide a spread for a single verdict. The five closest comparable sales within half a mile (bedrooms within one, living area within 15%) sold between January 14, 2026 and July 2, 2026; they are listed on this page.

How many homes sold in West Park?

5 homes closed in West Park between July 16, 2025 and July 16, 2026, with a Median price of $370,000 and a Median of $355 per square foot across all sizes. Per Realtracs closings and listings.

How has the market around 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville changed since it sold?

Since the sale, homes in West Park sold for a median $312/sq ft in the 12 months to November 18, 2026, about the same as $312/sq ft in the 12 months to July 16, 2026, when this home closed (12 and 8 closings, per Realtracs). That is a measure of the area, not a value for this home.

How are homes under contract near 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville priced?

Homes under contract in Nashville 37209 on November 18, 2026 were listed at a median $370/sq ft, 3.9% above the median list price of $356/sq ft for those that closed there in the six months to November 18, 2026 (31 under contract, 209 closed, per Realtracs). These are asking prices, not sale prices: a direction, not a forecast.

How does the sale price of 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville compare with its county appraised value?

It sold for $255,000, about 12% below its $288,300 county appraised value on the Davidson County record.

What schools is 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville zoned for?

5916 Carl Pl, Nashville is zoned for Cockrill Elementary, Moses McKissack Middle, Pearl Cohn Magnet High School. Attendance zones and enrollment change, verify current zoning with the Metro Nashville Public Schools district.

How do I find homes for sale near 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville?

Ask Grant Hammond, Compass RE, through the form on this page or call or text (615) 945-7123; he can send active listings and recent sales in West Park as they come up.

Who can tell me more about 5916 Carl Pl, Nashville?

Grant Hammond, Compass RE (TN Broker), with 25+ years and $1B+ in Middle Tennessee sales. Use the question form on this page.

Ask a questionCallText